Best Charming Pizzerias In Milwaukee Near Me

Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar Transfer Pizzeria Café Pizzeria Scotty Riverwest Pizza Lisa's Pizzeria Fixture Pizza Pub Riverfront Pizzeria Bar & Grill Classic Slice Restaurant WI Wy'east Pizza Sal's Pizza Milwaukee Maria's Pizza Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante Tenuta's Italian Restaurant Proof Pizza Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Ian's Pizza Cream City Vinchi's Pizza Brick 3 Pizza Alphonso's The Original

1. Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar - Lower East Side

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 905 reviews

1724 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Address Website WhatsApp
Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar: what do users think?

Jim Ackerman: A classic joint with classic food.

Mehgan: Definitely old school. But if you like thin crust pizza, this is your place.

Brandon Riviara: Nice cracker crust. Favorite pizza in the city

2. Transfer Pizzeria Café - Clock Tower Acres

Verified

Verified

· 1436 reviews

101 W Mitchell St, Milwaukee, WI 53204

Address Website WhatsApp
Transfer Pizzeria Café: what do users think?

jennifer muryn: . Try the allium pizza and caeser. They must make all foods on site. It's fresh and delicious. Shout out to Joseph! Best Server Ever!!!Vegetarian options: Pesto

ELVIRA ROCKWELL: Let's just start with the art and the layout, a visual feast, especially with the blacklight art and the wraparound layout of the restaurant. I always wander because I'm a firm believer in the old saying the devil is in detail, and u should always watch for the tail. I really liked the back bar not in use because the artwork on that wall reminded me of aboriginal art. The food was superb. I had a garlic pizza with bacon. Omg just sumptuous. The thin crust had the perfect amount of crunch and tasted so good. Along with it, I had a dark beer and a cocktail. Both were amazing. Lastly, I had the limoncello and flour less chocolate cake, and both of the witch was magically decadent and so worth it. I was downing milk along the way because born wisconsinite and nothing compliments dark chocolate like milk. The service was fast, and the waiters were perfect and funny.

Paul Ardoin: are fantastic. Great, attentive service, high quality beer selection too.Vegetarian options: Many vegetarian pizza optionsParking: Never had a problem finding street parking close to the restaurant

omar juarez: 披薩很美味,而且總是煮得很完美。停車場:在附近找到停車位從來沒有問題。

Chris Shook: 喜歡無麩質披薩和優質的服務。特殊餐點:很棒的無麩質外殼,喜歡大蒜醬的選擇。
Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 611 reviews

9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis, WI 53227

Address Website WhatsApp

4. Riverwest Pizza - Riverwest

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 355 reviews

53212, 930 E Wright St, Milwaukee, WI 53212

Address Website WhatsApp
Riverwest Pizza: what do users think?

Joe D: Enjoyed the pizza a lot. I was expecting a classic Milwaukee cracker crust. What I got was more like a NY crust with the toppings and sauce flavor profile of a Milwaukee thin. It was a nice fusion.My only complaint was that the restaurant had the vague smell of a sewer backup. Hopefully that was just a one-time anomaly.

Nick F Maltezos: Had it delivered, had to warm it up a little because of the distance, but this pizza is fire! I have a ballestreris and Marcos by me and I would take this riverwerst pizza over both of those classic icons.Food: 5/5 …

Thomas LinScents: Garlic Bread was one of the best I've ever had. Nice and buttery. We ordered 2 pizzas and I am so glad they didn't cut it into squared like most other bars. PIZZA was so damm good and the service was amazing as well.. I will definitely be back. Can't wait to eat my leftover pies... yummy

sarah anderson: Really good pizza. The owner is amazing. The interior space is beautiful and the outdoor space in the summer time is really nice, too.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly place.

5. Lisa's Pizzeria - Cambridge Heights

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 385 reviews

2961 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211

Address Website WhatsApp
Lisa's Pizzeria: what do users think?

Lois Wood: Was in town for the weekend and discovered some awesomeness right on Oakland Ave! The new owners are so friendly, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere was very relaxing. But the best part was the food - love that they’ve managed to keep some classic recipes while expanding my tastebuds in terms of flavor combos. Try the Hannah’s Favorite and thank me later, and save room for dessert - the tiramisu is delicious!

Sarah Moleski: I was in Milwaukee for a family gathering and we decided to go to Lisa’s Pizza. What a cute place. The owners Dean and Hannah were Johnny on the spot. At the ready with a menu, drink, answer to a question. The food was super awesome. We tried the Hannah’s pizza. Pepperoni with ricotta cheese and a hot honey drizzle. I will admit, that kind of pizza is not something I would order but I will now. It was fantastic. I think they have a little gold mine on their hands and I wish them nothing but the best!! I definitely will be back!

Mel Brousseau: kept what worked and added their own amazing additions, backed by their own developing culinary backgrounds and experiences. For example, along with the traditional sauce that made Lisa's pizza so delicious, there is also Hannah's own dessert recipes, an espresso martini made with Dean's own cold brew coffee recipe and the garlic bread, also created by Dean.While small changes have been made to the interior, with more slowly on the way, you will still find the dining room dimly lit and intimate. Although service was a little slow to start, our girl who seemed to be running the whole show did the best she could. Then Dean arrived, and he did an excellent job engaging and assisting us. He was kind enough to answer all our questions and make recommendations.The large cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion pizza we shared was fantastic and made with a generous amount of toppings. The combo plate veggies had a crispy coating, which kept their texture tender but not soft. The cheesy garlic bread was to die for. One of, if not THE best, I've ever had. DO NOT go here without ordering some! Then there's the Tiramisu. WOW. You could taste the coffee, although not overwhelmingly so, and the cream was fluffy and not overly sweet.Lisa's has been a Milwaukee staple, and it was wonderful to experience the classic flavors that brought us back, as well as new flavors that will keep us coming back for more!

Anthony: I came back! Below is my updated review:I love their margarita pizza "The Margaret"; I ordered a whole pizza to myself, and the leftovers still tasted great the next day! The ingredients taste fresh and of great quality, and I LOVE the sauce! The service was great, and this was the thing I was critical about last time; I'm happy it has improved! Also, I tried their sausage pizza, and it's the best sausage pizza I've ever had; normally I think sausage pizzas are not going to be that good, but something about their sausage recipe really hits home for me. Thanks for the good food Lisa's, I'll be back soon!

Lauren Wren: Typically we love Lisa’s pizza. We decided to give the Detroit style pizza a try….we will not be ordering this in the future and will stick to the tavern style pizza

Quashae Coleman: Really good pizza. Love the onion rings. Very friendly guy who takes the orders!Recommended dishes Onion Rings …

6. Fixture Pizza Pub - Walker's Point

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 809 reviews

623 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204, United States

Address Website WhatsApp
Fixture Pizza Pub: what do users think?

F Huntington: Recommended dishes Deep Dish Pizza with Sausage and Giardiniera

Sarah G: Highly recommend! The pizza is always delicious. The Italian pasta dishes are wonderful. The pesto noodle dish is one of my favorites. My son loves the spaghetti and meatballs. They have so many different food options. I want to try it all.We love the thin crust pizza, the sauce is one of our favorites. Everything taste so fresh and homemade. The restaurant is run very well, it gets busy so definitely call ahead if you can.

Rachel Jadin: Vegetarian options: Took my boyfriend's parents here- one is vegetarian, the other is gluten free, and they were so impressed and always existed to go back. This is easily both my boyfriend's and my favorite pizza in Milwaukee!Dietary restrictions: Took my boyfriend's parents here- one is vegetarian, the other is gluten free, and they were so impressed and always existed to go back. This is easily both my boyfriend's and my favorite pizza in Milwaukee!

7. Riverfront Pizzeria Bar & Grill - Historic Third Ward

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 642 reviews

509 E Erie St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Address Website WhatsApp
Riverfront Pizzeria Bar & Grill: what do users think?

Erin H: . Plus, she made my aunt’s day.. it was her bday and Allie made her the sweetest little dessert 3 thank you for this wonderful experience

Traci Grandgeorge: Great family style options for large groups.Recommended dishes Taco Pizza …

Todd: Good pizza in a great location!We catered a party buffet line. Everything was very tastyDietary restrictions: YesWheelchair accessibility: Yes

Stephanie Kuenzli: Delicious pizza with quality ingredients. Fairly nice atmosphere, though off-season isn't the time to enjoy the river. Service was ok... Host and Server was a bit awkward as humans. Probably shouldn't be in customer service. Was a bit uncomfortable. We got our food quickly because the restaurant was empty.The Garden Goddess with arugula on top was pretty amazing. Yum!Vegetarian options: You can create your own pizzas with numerous veggies. Cauliflower, broccoli, tomato, artichoke, arugula, etc. Say no to cheese if you wish.
Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 981 reviews

2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Address Website WhatsApp
Classic Slice Restaurant WI: what do users think?

emily held: Very good pizza, but in my opinion a bit overpriced.

9. Wy'east Pizza - Hawthorne Glen

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 292 reviews

5601 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208

Address Website WhatsApp
Wy'east Pizza: what do users think?

Will Cappon: Vegetarian options: Vegan pie option and cheese/veggie only offeringsFood: 4/5Recommended dishes Margharita Pizza Recommendation for vegetarians Somewhat recommend Vegetarian offerings Clearly labeled vegetarian dishes …

michelle ramos: Love their creative pizzas!
Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 509 reviews

838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203

Address Website WhatsApp
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana: what do users think?

P. Kahn: . You should definitely check this place out.

Lynette Shepherd: and it was amazing. We started with perfectly floured, crispy eggplant! Also, delicious! But it was Megan, our server, that really made our dinner experience special! Can't wait to go back!

11. Sal's Pizza Milwaukee - Avenues West

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 314 reviews

2040 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53233

Address Website WhatsApp

12. Maria's Pizza - Jackson Park

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 838 reviews

5025 W Forest Home Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53219

Address Website WhatsApp
Maria's Pizza: what do users think?

joeseph karvonen: BEST PIZZA SINCE 1969 SINCE I ATE IT ON GREENFIELD AVE

13. Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante - Wauwatosa

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 1513 reviews

812 N 68th St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Address Website WhatsApp
Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante: what do users think?

Paul Rinaldi: Fantastic food, loved their pork and pizzas. Their garlic bread was delicious and balanced. Their servers and bussers were polite and friendly.There's an accessible ramp on the patio as well as a staircase.There's a fair number of parking spots as well. I look forward to coming again for a date night or a celebration.Wheelchair accessibility: There is an accessible ramp from the parking lot up to the patio and into the first floor of the building. There is seating on this floor.

Jesus Hernandez: There are many places that sell pizzas but I really liked this place because of the baked flavor and the original flavor.Parking: It is located at the back of the restaurant and there is an alley that leads out in front of the main entrance.

Janine Hering: Never been and I don't know why. This is now one of our top three favorite pizza spots. Thin crust with crispy edges, just the right amount of sauce and they don't skimp on the cheese or the toppings. The cheese bread was also very good. Jaki was great - attentive and very friendly. Absolutely recommend!Dietary restrictions: For those with Celiac disease or who choose to eat gluten free, they have gf garlic bread, cauliflower crust and flourless chocolate cake.Parking: Parking lot behind the building and plenty of street parking.

14. Tenuta's Italian Restaurant - Bay View

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 881 reviews

2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Address Website WhatsApp
Tenuta's Italian Restaurant: what do users think?

Steve Kolb: Great food and service! I had the mushroom ravioli. I will be returning sometime.

Kat Stewart: Non traditional store front that transports you to Italy with every dish they serve. A real gem amongst the dining scene of the area with fabulous courses start to finish. The pasta is cooked to a precision that only experience and masterful repetition can bring. If you want to be taken back to a dinner at nonnas house under soft candle light make a reservation here and enjoy a glass of wine with those you cherish.

Thomas Bakko: The food and atmosphere here were great. I ordered the Lasagna for my primi and the Marsala for my secondi. Both were delicious and were literally steaming when they came out. Not sure they know what primi and secondi mean though, both dishes came at the same time and were full sized entrees. I probably should have realized that but oh well, got to try two dishes and the price was not outlandish.The staff were very friendly and attentive, but not too in your face. Exactly how I believe service should be. I would eat here again anytime

15. Proof Pizza - East Town

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 35 reviews

139 E Kilbourn Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Address Website WhatsApp
Proof Pizza: what do users think?

Sandi Landowski: The pizza was delicious! The daughter and I shared a Proof special pizza and the antipasta salad. There is so much flavor and very decently priced. They are accessible. However, seating is very difficult and very limited. The restaurant is a walk-up, first come, first served counter service, but you can place an order with the wait staff in the small dining area. The dining area is more of a lounge for St. Kate's hotel. A few very small tables were occupied, and couches with small, short coffee tables. We ate with our plates on our laps. They had live music which was nice, but it was very loud with the people trying to talk over the music. We were here on Friday around 5:00 pm.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp located outside the entrance to Proof pizza. There are also ramps inside the dining/lounge area to access the various levels. It was difficult for my daughter to eat her meal on her lap.

Aastha Chandra: listen i know this is a nicer version of blaze pizza but this was legit the best pizza we've both ever had. we built our own and added ricotta in addition to the regular marinara as well as truffle honey and they made a world of difference. i'm still dreaming about this pizza, honestly.they took the st kate arts hotel food credit that you can get from expedia/other travel site bookings so it was free for us. will so be back next time i'm in milwaukee

Scott W: We have tried the other food venues at the St. Kate and like them. This was the first time that we ate at Proof. Got nice welcome by the staff and an explanation of the food options, and the process. Ordered a couple of small pizzas. Waited for about 20 mins and the pager/buzzer went off.Both pizzas were fresh, hot and flavorful. However, it was under cooked. Crust was good, the middle was not. Other reviews have complained about the pizza being soggy. It was horrible, but could have been better. I would try again and ask that it be done more.Took the pizzas to the bar area and got to listen to an amazing jazz/pop ensemble. Overall, it was a good experience.

16. Ian's Pizza Milwaukee - The East Side

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 1440 reviews

2035 E North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Address Website WhatsApp
Ian's Pizza Milwaukee: what do users think?

Bryan Lassner: Vegetarian options: There are always many vegetarian slicesDietary restrictions: Lots of vegan optionsRecommended dishes Slice of Pizza, Mac N’ Cheese Pizza Slice, Vegan Recommendation for vegetarians Highly recommend Vegetarian offerings Large vegetarian selection …

Steve Crumbaugh: My twenty something son likes this ready to eat, by the slice pizza place more than I do, but I am more of a traditional pizza guy. The strength of the place is the variety of sometimes quirky pizzas. The restaurant and staff are friendly and inviting. Half the choices were vegetarian, vegan, or gluten friendly. We enjoyed our slices and I would recommend this place to friends.

TRNQL Nail Therapy: Great service, delicious pizza.

Eternal Resonance2: Cant complainWheelchair accessibility: They will make your wheelchair into a pizza wheelchair. Think transformersRecommended dishes Slice of Pizza, Mac N’ Cheese Pizza Slice, Vegan …

17. Ian's Pizza Cream City - East Town

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 1288 reviews

146 E Juneau Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Address Website WhatsApp
Ian's Pizza Cream City: what do users think?

Faith Graham: Food: 5/5

htx herbivore: they’re known for, this location also had a nice dining area upstairs with games lining the walls. My personal favorite is the baked penne pizza, but they have a ton of great slices and a variety of different options

Paige Buschman: I have been here twice for one thing and one thing only: the Mac and cheese pizza. This time, I was pleasantly surprised to also get to have another vegetarian option and that was by far the best part--having so many creative veg pizza options. Big fan of Ian's. The staff were kind of a mess and the physical space was tight but I'm not gonna take points off for that bc this is about the pizza.

18. Vinchi's Pizza - Bay View

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 58 reviews

3158 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Address WhatsApp

19. Brick 3 Pizza - Westown

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 552 reviews

1107 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203

Address Website WhatsApp
Brick 3 Pizza: what do users think?

Athena Laitinen: Food: 5/5Recommended dishes

Yonason Meadows: I placed a very big order for an event at my company. Everything was perfect. The Pizza was hot and ready right on time. Ordering and paying online was a breeze. The owner of the restaurant was very accommodating and so nice! The staff at my company absolutely loved the pizza and the house salad. Definitely recommend, and, if we have the opportunity in the future, would definitely order from Brick 3 again!

20. Alphonso's The Original - West Allis

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 413 reviews

1119 S 108th St, West Allis, WI 53214

Address Website WhatsApp
Alphonso's The Original: what do users think?

J Lemke: not great or worth getting unless you just love oily soggy bread with no sauce to go with it- it’s Expensive. 48$ for family special.- Atmosphere- felt like early 90s/80s in there. Blockbuster tape on the wall was a nice touch.- Staff was friendly and inviting-thanks!

Griffin Roberts: C’mon! This place is BOSS! Pizza is KILLER! Decor is unreal. It’s gonna take a while to get through their whole menu, but Ima do it! Amazing classic pies and ridiculous specialty pies. Location is also convenient, and well worth a trip here from ANYWHERE in the MKE metro and beyond! PLUS, these owners AND their crew are standup folks and have EARNED your support.

Jim B.: Delicious Pizza and Lightning Rods. We got one pepperoni, one veggie and one pickle pizza along with the lightning rods. I was skeptical on the pickle pizza, but it was good, and found myself craving another slice. Everything was super delicious and the staff extra super friendly! While waiting to pick up the pizza, it was a nostalgic trip into the 1980's with an 8-bit Nintendo, hundreds of stickers, action figures and other 80's memorabilia...enough to keep 2 children occupied for a few minutes. I hope to order another round of pizza soon!

Ericka G: The pizza here is so good. We like the Super bee crust pizza with pep and sausage and you can’t forget the lightning rod mozzarella stick! Everyone there is so friendly! One of our favorite pizza spots! Plus you can’t go wrong with all the 80’s memorabillia, the Nintendo game system you can play while you wait for your pizza or the last time I was there, the kids show Guts playing was on tv.

add a comment of charming pizzerias in Milwaukee

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.